Suit might settle questions about UFO in Pennsylvania

NASA must comb its records for information on 1965 Kecksburg incident

Tuesday, December 25, 2007 2:56 AM
By Sean D. Hamill

CHICAGO TRIBUNE

ANNIE O'NEILL | CHICAGO TRIBUNE

Bill Bulebush, left, with UFO expert Stan Gordon, says he witnessed an unidentified flying object land in Kecksburg, Pa., in 1965, although the government says otherwise. A replica of the acorn-shaped craft is behind them.

KECKSBURG, Pa. -- The U.S. government says nothing of note happened in this small town in the hills of southwestern Pennsylvania at 4:47 p.m. on Dec. 9, 1965. A meteor might have passed by, but no alien ship or Russian space probe fell to Earth, as many here believe.

Still, Bill Bulebush, 82, says he knows what he saw, heard and smelled, despite the doubts of the government and others in this community 40 miles southeast of Pittsburgh.

"I looked up and saw it flying overhead, and it was sizzling," said Bulebush, a retired truck driver. "I found it in the woods down there (in a valley), and I got to it 15 to 20 minutes after it landed. I saw it 10 to 15 feet away from behind a big tree -- because I was worried it might blow up -- and it smelled like sulfur or rotten eggs and was shaped like a huge acorn, about the size of a VW."

Other people said that shortly thereafter, dozens of Army soldiers and three members of the Air Force showed up, and later that night a flatbed military truck took the object away.

Despite such accounts, the government has been "trying to make it out like we're a bunch of liars," Bulebush said. But now he and his fellow believers might have their best chance yet to prove their case.

A recent settlement in a 4-year-long Freedom of Information Act court battle requires NASA to meticulously comb for documents about the Kecksburg incident and report back periodically to the judge overseeing the case.

The lawsuit was filed in December 2003 in the District of Columbia by Leslie Kean, a freelance journalist, with financial support from the SciFi Channel, which ran a show that year titled The New Roswell: Kecksburg Exposed.

Kean was asked by SciFi in 2002 to find a solid UFO case, one with credible witnesses and possible physical evidence, to serve as a test case. She created the Coalition for Freedom of Information to support the effort and to look further into other "unexplained aerial phenomena."

Part of Kean's own criteria, despite SciFi's title for the Kecksburg show, was to pick a case as far removed as possible from the 1947 incident in Roswell, N.M. -- thought by many to be a crashed alien spaceship but later revealed to be a top-secret research balloon.

"The types that go to Roswell and parade in the street in costumes, we try to stay far, far away from that," she said.

Kean pressed the case after she filed a Freedom of Information Act request earlier in 2003 and NASA said it couldn't find any documents related to Kecksburg. But Kean already knew the space agency, which had a program in the 1960s to recover and analyze space debris, had some documents.

Stan Gordon, a well-known UFO and Bigfoot researcher with whom Kean was working, had information he got in response to a request he sent NASA in the 1990s.

"In the beginning, they probably saw Leslie's request and thought, 'Oh, she's after UFOs,' " said her attorney, Lee Helfrich of Washington, D.C. "Maybe they just didn't treat it seriously at first."

They do now.

After NASA turned over about 1,000 pages of documents that failed to adequately address Kean's request, the case boiled over on March 20 for federal Judge Emmet Sullivan, who had tried to move NASA along for more than three years.

According to a transcript of the hearing that day, he angrily referred to NASA's search efforts as a "ball of yarn" that never fully answered the request, adding: "I can sense the plaintiff's frustration because I'm frustrated."

A settlement was reached Oct. 17. Over eight pages it specifies how NASA will make a new search for records and that both sides will be required to report back to Sullivan periodically, starting Dec. 17. For not being responsive, NASA agreed to pay Kean $50,000 in attorneys' fees and costs.

In a statement, NASA would say only that it was "in the process of conducting another records search."

On Dec. 17, Kean and her attorney received the first batch of documents. NASA sent her 689 pages of Form 135s, which are inventory sheets that indicate what is in boxes and files in NASA's archives.

Based on a first read through the documents, from which Kean will select files for NASA to pull out and review for any documents related to the Kecksburg incident, she said she's "cautiously optimistic" that they'll turn up something.

"I asked my attorney if she found the 'Kecksburg UFO Explained' file," Kean said with a laugh. "She said, 'Not yet.' But I'm still hopeful."